Chapter 7
Student Discipline, Attendance, and the Right to be in School
What’s in this chapter?
All students have the right to attend school, and to attend school without discrimination. Being excluded from the school or the classroom can have a significant negative impact on a student’s learning, their social connections, and their mental health; in many cases it could even be a violation of their rights.
This section reviews issues that can impact a student’s right to be in school, including suspensions and expulsions, the appeal rights related to those decisions, and more general rights and obligations associated with student discipline. It also reviews the issues of seclusion and restraint.
In the previous section of this guidebook, we covered the Ontario Human Rights Code and the education system’s duty to accommodate the needs of students with disabilities. It is important to remember that even where a student may be showing “unacceptable behaviour,” if that behavior is connected to a disability, then the school board has a duty to look at the student individually before taking steps that may affect the student negatively. This includes any potential discipline.
BACKGROUND ON SCHOOL DISCIPLINE
The province of Ontario passed the Safe Schools Act in 2000 and subsequently made related changes to the Education Act. The Safe Schools Act gave school boards more power to suspend and expel students, among other things. Concerns about the potential discriminatory impact of this legislation and policies were raised by the Ontario Human Rights Commission (OHRC). In 2005, the OHRC filed a human rights claim related to concerns that the “zero tolerance” approach of the ‘safe schools’ provisions had a disproportionate impact on students with disabilities and racialized students.
In 2008, the Education Act was amended to transition from a “zero tolerance” to a “progressive discipline” approach. This is the framework and approach that is supposed to be applied today by school boards and is discussed throughout this section.
For more information specific to student discipline, you can look at regulations of the Education Act and Policy and Program Memoranda (PPMs) that are discussed earlier in this guide and specifically impact the right to be in school. For example:
-
- Reg. 472/07 – Behaviour, Discipline and Safety of Pupils2
- This regulation of the Education Act includes mitigating factors that school boards need to consider when determining suspension and expulsion. These are outlined further in this section.
- Reg. 472/07 – Behaviour, Discipline and Safety of Pupils2
-
- Policy/Program Memorandum No. 145 – Progressive discipline and promoting positive student behaviour3
- This PPM provides directions to school boards on their policies concerning progressive discipline. Each school board is required to have its own progressive discipline policy in place.
- Policy/Program Memorandum No. 145 – Progressive discipline and promoting positive student behaviour3
-
- Ministry of Education – Caring and Safe Schools in Ontario: Supporting Students with Special Needs Through Progressive Discipline, Kindergarten to Grade 124
- This resource document is available on the Ministry of Education’s website. It is meant to, among other things, provide information about strategies and resources to help address behavioural challenges for students, in particular students with special education needs.
- Ministry of Education – Caring and Safe Schools in Ontario: Supporting Students with Special Needs Through Progressive Discipline, Kindergarten to Grade 124
SUSPENSIONS
Only a principal can make the decision to suspend a student. Suspensions are recorded in a student’s Ontario Student Record (OSR).
Actions that can lead to a suspension fall into two general categories:
The “MAY” suspend category
The “MUST” suspend category (suspension, investigation, and possible expulsion)
Acts a principal may suspend for: (s. 306)
Acts a principal must suspend for: (s. 310)
(When a student is suspended pending a potential expulsion decision, the principal must conduct an investigation as part of the process to decide whether or not to recommend expulsion of the student.)
- Uttering a threat to inflict serious bodily harm on another person.
- Possessing alcohol, illegal drugs or, unless the student is a medical cannabis user, cannabis.
- Being under the influence of alcohol or, unless the student is a medical cannabis user, cannabis.
- Swearing at a teacher or at another person in a position of authority.
- Committing an act of vandalism that causes extensive damage to school property at the student’s school or to property located on the premises of the student’s school.
- Possessing a weapon, including a firearm.
- Using a weapon to cause or to threaten bodily harm to another person.
- Committing physical assault on another person that causes bodily harm requiring treatment by a medical practitioner.
- Committing sexual assault.
- Trafficking in weapons or in illegal drugs.
- Committing robbery.
- Giving alcohol or cannabis to a minor.
- Bullying (including cyberbullying).
- Any other activity that is an activity for which a principal may suspend a student under a policy of the school board.
- Bullying, if the student has previously been suspended for engaging in bullying, and if the student’s continued presence in the school creates an unacceptable risk to the safety of another person.
- Any activity for which a student can be suspended that is motivated by bias, prejudice, or hate based on race, national or ethnic origin, language, colour, religion, sex, age, mental or physical disability, sexual orientation, gender identity, gender expression, or any other similar factor.
- Any other activity for which a student can be suspended under school board policy.
Students in Grades 4 to 12 can be suspended for the activities listed above.
The principal cannot consider suspension for students in junior kindergarten (JK) to Grade 3 for the activities listed above;5 instead, the principal must consider what positive behaviour supports can be provided to the student.
Students in Grades 4 to 12 can be suspended for the activities listed above.
Students in junior kindergarten (JK) to Grade 3 cannot be suspended for any of the above actions unless the principal has performed an investigation.6
The “MAY” suspend category
Acts a principal may suspend for: (s. 306)
- Uttering a threat to inflict serious bodily harm on another person.
- Possessing alcohol, illegal drugs or, unless the student is a medical cannabis user, cannabis.
- Being under the influence of alcohol or, unless the student is a medical cannabis user, cannabis.
- Swearing at a teacher or at another person in a position of authority.
- Committing an act of vandalism that causes extensive damage to school property at the student’s school or to property located on the premises of the student’s school.
- Bullying (including cyberbullying).
- Any other activity that is an activity for which a principal may suspend a student under a policy of the school board.
Students in Grades 4 to 12 can be suspended for the activities listed above.
The principal cannot consider suspension for students in junior kindergarten (JK) to Grade 3 for the activities listed above;5 instead, the principal must consider what positive behaviour supports can be provided to the student.
The “MUST” suspend category (suspension, investigation, and possible expulsion)
Acts a principal must suspend for: (s. 310)
(When a student is suspended pending a potential expulsion decision, the principal must conduct an investigation as part of the process to decide whether or not to recommend expulsion of the student.)
- Possessing a weapon, including a firearm.
- Using a weapon to cause or to threaten bodily harm to another person.
- Committing physical assault on another person that causes bodily harm requiring treatment by a medical practitioner.
- Committing sexual assault.
- Trafficking in weapons or in illegal drugs.
- Committing robbery.
- Giving alcohol or cannabis to a minor.
- Bullying, if the student has previously been suspended for engaging in bullying, and if the student’s continued presence in the school creates an unacceptable risk to the safety of another person.
- Any activity for which a student can be suspended that is motivated by bias, prejudice, or hate based on race, national or ethnic origin, language, colour, religion, sex, age, mental or physical disability, sexual orientation, gender identity, gender expression, or any other similar factor.
- Any other activity for which a student can be suspended under school board policy.
Students in Grades 4 to 12 can be suspended for the activities listed above.
Students in junior kindergarten (JK) to Grade 3 cannot be suspended for any of the above actions unless the principal has performed an investigation.6
Before deciding to suspend and/or expel a student, the principal must consider each student individually. Principals must consider:7
- The student’s history.
- Whether a progressive discipline approach has been used with the student.
- Whether the activity for which the student may be or is being suspended or expelled was related to any harassment of the student because of their race, ethnic origin, religion, disability, gender or sexual orientation or to any other protected ground.
- How the suspension would affect the student’s ongoing education.
- The age of the student.
If the student has an Individual Education Plan (IEP), the principal must also consider:8
- Whether the behaviour was a manifestation of a disability identified in the student’s IEP.
- Whether the appropriate individualized accommodation has been provided.
- Whether the suspension is likely to result in an aggravation or worsening of the student’s behavior or conduct.
WHAT HAPPENS IF I DISAGREE WITH A SUSPENSION DECISION?
You can appeal a decision about a suspension to the school board. The school board should give you information about your rights to appeal and the process at the time of suspension. This also includes cases where you believe that the school did not consider factors such as whether appropriate individualized accommodation was provided.
If you want to appeal a suspension, you must send notice in writing to the superintendent of the school board within 10 school days of the start of the suspension. The appeal must then be heard within 15 school days after the school board receives your notice of appeal, unless you and the school board agree to an extension.
On appeal, the school board can either confirm the suspension, reduce the length of the suspension, or cancel the suspension.
WHAT HAPPENS DURING A SUSPENSION AND RETURN TO SCHOOL?
School boards need to offer programs for students who have been suspended for more than five days. If a student is suspended for more than five school days, the school principal will also hold a re-entry meeting with the teacher, student, and parents.
The Ministry of Education has also published a number of Policy/Program Memoranda that give directives about school board obligations during suspensions and expulsions. These include:
- PPM 141 – School board programs for students on long-term suspension
- For a long-term suspension (more than 5 school days), school boards must offer at least one program for students. In the written notice of suspension, the school board must provide information on the board program to which the student on a long-term suspension has been assigned.
- School boards are expected to provide homework packages for students who have been suspended for less than six days, to help ensure that the student does not fall behind in their school work.
- PPM 142 – School board programs for expelled students
- School boards are required to provide at least one program for students who have been expelled from any school within the board.
- School boards are also required to reassign a student who has been expelled from only his or her school to another school within the board.
Below is a summary of the steps required for suspended students, as outlined by the Ministry of Education:9
| SUSPENSION LENGTH | PLANNING MEETING | STUDENT ACTION PLAN: Academic component |
STUDENT ACTION PLAN: Non-academic component |
RE-ENTRY MEETING |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1-5 school days | Not required | Not required | Not required | Not required |
| 6-10 school days | Not required | |||
| 11-20 school days |
Expulsions
As outlined above, some types of suspensions are given in specific situations where the principal is also deciding whether to recommend an expulsion of the student to the school board. There are two kinds of expulsions: 1) being expelled from a school; or, 2) being expelled from every school in the school board.
The school principal must investigate before deciding to recommend whether a student should be expelled. The student is suspended while the principal investigates (see above).
What happens after the principal’s investigation and considerations?
If the principal does not recommend expulsion:
The principal can confirm the suspension and duration of the suspension.
The principal can confirm the suspension but shorten its duration, even if the suspension has already been served, and amend the record of the suspension accordingly.
The principal can withdraw the suspension and expunge the record of the suspension, even if the suspension has already been served.10
If the principal recommends expulsion:
At the conclusion of the investigation, if the principal decides to recommend to the school board that the pupil be expelled, the principal must prepare a report that contains the following:
- A summary of the principal’s findings.
- The principal’s recommendation as to whether the pupil should be expelled from their school only, or from all schools of the board.
- The principal’s recommendation as to the type of school that might benefit the pupil (if they are expelled from their school only), or the type of program for expelled pupils that might benefit the pupil (if they are expelled from all schools of the board).11
If the school board does not expel a pupil, the board shall either:
Confirm the suspension and duration of the suspension;
Confirm the suspension, but shorten its duration (even if the suspension that is under appeal has already been served, and order that the record of the suspension be amended accordingly); or,
Quash the suspension and order that the record of the suspension be removed, even if the suspension that is under appeal has already been served.13
The school board makes the final decision to expel a student.
The school board will hold an expulsion hearing to make the decision. After completing an expulsion hearing, the school board shall decide whether to expel the student, and if the student is to be expelled, whether the student is expelled from their school only, or from all schools of the board.12
What happens after the principal’s investigation and considerations?
What happens after the principal’s investigation and considerations?
If the principal does not recommend expulsion:
The principal can confirm the suspension and duration of the suspension.
The principal can confirm the suspension but shorten its duration, even if the suspension has already been served, and amend the record of the suspension accordingly.
The principal can withdraw the suspension and expunge the record of the suspension, even if the suspension has already been served.10
If the principal recommends expulsion:
At the conclusion of the investigation, if the principal decides to recommend to the school board that the pupil be expelled, the principal must prepare a report that contains the following:
- A summary of the principal’s findings.
- The principal’s recommendation as to whether the pupil should be expelled from their school only, or from all schools of the board.
- The principal’s recommendation as to the type of school that might benefit the pupil (if they are expelled from their school only), or the type of program for expelled pupils that might benefit the pupil (if they are expelled from all schools of the board).11
If the school board does not expel a pupil, the board shall either:
Confirm the suspension and duration of the suspension;
Confirm the suspension, but shorten its duration (even if the suspension that is under appeal has already been served, and order that the record of the suspension be amended accordingly); or,
Quash the suspension and order that the record of the suspension be removed, even if the suspension that is under appeal has already been served.13
The school board makes the final decision to expel a student.
The school board will hold an expulsion hearing to make the decision. After completing an expulsion hearing, the school board shall decide whether to expel the student, and if the student is to be expelled, whether the student is expelled from their school only, or from all schools of the board.12
Exclusions and modified days
The Education Act gives principals the power to exclude a student when their presence, in the principal’s judgment, becomes harmful to others. This power is found at section 265(1)(m) of the Education Act, and is sometimes referred to as the “Exclusion Provision.” This provision states that it is the “duty” of a principal, subject to an appeal to the board, to refuse to admit to the school or classroom a person whose presence in the school or classroom would, in their judgement, be detrimental to the physical or mental well-being of other students.
Exclusions are different from suspensions. If a student is suspended, the student has a number of additional rights. For example, the Education Act specifically says that a suspension cannot be longer than 20 days. While exclusions should not be indefinite, the Education Act does not have a similar time limit for exclusions.
Policy and Procedure Memoranda 145 – “Progressive Discipline and Promoting Positive Student Behaviour” specifically refers to the Exclusion Provision and says that it should not be used as a form of discipline. If a principal does decide that it is necessary to exclude a student from school, the principal is expected to notify the student’s parents of the exclusion as soon as possible in the circumstances, and to inform them of their right to appeal.
WHAT HAPPENS TO A STUDENT WHEN THEY ARE EXCLUDED?
In some cases, the school may deliver a letter formally telling the student that they have been excluded and giving reasons for the exclusion.
There is a right to appeal an exclusion of a student.
If you believe the decision to exclude a student is unfair, it is important to look at the school board’s appeal process. Some school boards have policies that specifically talk about Exclusions. You can check your school’s website at any time to see if there are any specific policies that apply to your situation.
The appeal of an exclusion decision is heard by the Board of Trustees. The Board of Trustees can reverse the decision to exclude if they think it is wrong. The process and form of the appeal depends on the school board. Typically, an exclusion appeal is held in accordance with the Education Act, the school board’s policies, and any specific exclusion appeal guideline the school board may have. Sometimes, an exclusion appeal process will request that a documentation package be prepared by both the school board and the appellant (the student) to present to the Board of Trustees.
The Board of Trustees can either uphold the exclusion or set aside the exclusion (and may also make any related orders or directions depending on their decision).
It is important to consider contacting a lawyer or other qualified professional if you want to appeal a decision to exclude to the Board of Trustees, and/or if you are concerned whether any exclusions may violate a student’s human rights.
What if the school is asking the student to stay home for all or part of the school day?
The Education Act (specifically, O. Reg. 298 Operation of Schools – General) allows school boards to shorten the school day of an exceptional pupil to less than the normal hours of instruction. However, a school board should not shorten a school day for the school board’s own convenience—the decision or suggestion to shorten the length of a school day must be for the benefit of the student.
Modified days typically need to be approved by the school board superintendent in consultation with the student (where appropriate) and the student’s parents/caregivers. Modified days should only be done after other strategies (like additional classroom supports, changes to the IEP, etc.) have been considered and implemented.
The Education Act requires school staff to monitor the effectiveness of modified day attendance for a student, and to determine the earliest opportunity to increase the student’s instructional day.
If the school is suggesting a shortened school day for a student, some view this as a “partial” or “informal” exclusion. If you disagree with the decision or suggestion to shorten the length of a student’s school day, you should ask the school to give their reasons in writing.
Similarly, schools may also ask that a student be kept home on particular days – for example, in cases where teaching and/or support staff are unavailable. It is important to remember that a student has a right to be at school, and the school board needs to give valid reasons for their suggestions or decisions to keep a student out of school.
If your child is on a modified schedule and you feel that they could be attending more regularly, you have options. For example, you can contact the Special Education Advisory Committee (or a particular representative on that committee), and/or you can contact your school board trustee with an overview of the situation and your concerns.
Please see Chapter 3 where we outline places you can take your concerns about special education, starting at the school level up to the board of trustees.
SECLUSION ROOMS
Some students with disabilities benefit from spending time in quiet spaces, called ‘sensory rooms’ or ‘calming rooms.’ Students may access these rooms to help with self-regulation during the school day. However, some parents report that school staff also move students into these spaces against their will.
When we refer to ‘seclusion rooms,’ we are referring specifically to spaces where students may be separated from peers against their will, or for a reason that is not for their benefit. For example, some parents report that these spaces may be used to discipline students, where they are otherwise lacking accommodations.
In 2019, Autism Advocacy Ontario published the results of a survey of 568 special education students and their caregivers. 16% of students reported being secluded in a separate room or space that was either locked or physically barred by an education worker. Of these students:
- 73% were secluded more than six times;
- 57% were forcibly moved to the seclusion room and/or physically restrained while in the room;
- 50% indicated at least one instance of seclusion where the parent was not notified.
If you are concerned that your child may be placed in a seclusion room and that it will not be for their benefit, there are several steps you can take:
- Ask the Superintendent of Special Education if your school board has a policy on the use of seclusion rooms.
- Ask the school principal if the school has one or more spaces that are used to seclude students against their will. (As noted above, sometimes these rooms can also be accessed voluntarily by students who need a quiet and calming space).
- Ask your child’s teacher or the school principal if your child has been placed, or is at risk of being placed, in a seclusion room.
- Consider working with the school to create a Safety Plan for your child. More information about Student Safety Plans can be found on the Ministry of Education website.14
If your child has been placed in a seclusion room, you can:
- Set up a meeting with the classroom teacher and school principal to discuss why this happened. See Chapter 3 where we outline where you can escalate your concerns starting at the school level up to the school board.
- Create a Student Safety Plan so that school staff can (a) anticipate and prevent situations that lead to heightened stress while your child is at school, and (b) provide the resources necessary for your child to attend school safely and without undue stress. See Chapter 2 where we note your obligations in the duty to accommodate and participate in that process.
- Notify the Superintendent of Special Education and the Special Education Advisory Committee.
THE USE OF RESTRAINT ON STUDENTS
In 2019, Autism Advocacy Ontario published the results of a survey of 568 special education students and their caregivers. 23% reported that the student had been physically restrained. Of these:
- 66% reported being restrained more than six times;
- 35% of caregivers reported not being told of restraint use.
When we refer to ‘restraint,’ we mean physically stopping a student from being able to move. So for example someone holding a student in a chair and not letting them move away, holding them on the ground, or holding their shoulders and forcing them out of a classroom.
The use of physical restraint on students is not clearly addressed by the Education Act. However, it is important to remember that human rights law in Ontario says that education environments should be designed in a way that promotes integration, full participation, and respects the dignity of the student. See Chapter 6 for more information.
If you are concerned at all about the use of restraint in school, you can:
- Ask the Superintendent of Special Education if your school board has a policy on the use of restraint.
- Set up a meeting with the classroom teacher and school principal to understand if your child has been restrained, or is at risk of being restrained. See Chapter 3 where we outline where you can escalate your concerns starting at the school level up to the school board.
- Consider whether there is any Student Safety Plan in place, or if one needs to be created, so that school staff can (a) anticipate and prevent situations that lead to heightened stress while your child is at school, and (b) provide the resources necessary for your child to attend school safely and without undue stress.15 See Chapter 2 where we note your obligations in the duty to accommodate and participate in that process.
- Reach out to members of your school board’s Special Education Advisory Committee.
KEY TAKEAWAYS
Some key takeaways from Chapter 7:
- You have the right to be in school and can only be denied the right to go to school in specific circumstances.
- You have the right to appeal suspension, expulsion, and exclusion decisions.
- A student should not be excluded or disciplined for behaviour that is not accommodated.
- Modified days typically need to be approved by the school board superintendent in consultation with the student (where appropriate) and the student’s parents/caregivers.
- Human rights law in Ontario says that education environments should be designed in a way that promotes integration, full participation, and respects the dignity of the student.